Most often the result is not fully accessible; browser and assistive technology is inconsistent; and implementations vary across the web. This is why it’s always better to use native selects with HTML/web. (Native components is also a better choice for native apps.) Don’t forget that HTML selects can be styled with CSS; see these resources by Scott O’Hara, RTD, Filament Group, and LugoLabs.
If you must implement a custom select dropdown, you will most like need to use the ARIA listbox role, combobox role (which specifies a composite widget), and often a combination of those roles. The option role is also required and usually a few other ARIA attributes (for label, state, etc.).
Here are some great examples which will save many folks a lot of time—if you must customize!
- Anatomy of an Accessible Auto Suggest (UX Mastery) by Adem Cifcioglu
- Modified version by Web Axe author: Accessible Autosuggest Dropdown
- Custom Select by Deque Systems
- Combobo — accessible combobox module by Harris Schneiderman (of Deque Systems) combobo on github
- Building an accessible auto-complete (Slideshare) by @russmaxdesign and now Russ’ preso for ID24 on YouTube!
- Accessible Autocomplete by Adina Halter
- jQuery accessible autocomplete list by Nicolas Hoffmann
- Accessible Autocomplete examples by alphagov (gov.uk); related article about testing autocomplete.
- Basic autocomplete (activedescendent) CodePen by Heydon Pickering
- Collapsible Dropdown Listbox Example by W3C (from comments)
- Combobox with Listbox Popup Examples by W3C
- Gerard Cohen’s custom select: Presentation video (YouTube) / Web-based slide deck / code demo
- Styling a Select Like It’s 2019 by filament group
- Building an accessible autocomplete control by Adam Silver (Feb. 2020) demo
- <select> your poison by Sarah Higley (Dec. 2019)
- Under-Engineered Select Menus by Adrian Roselli
- Consistently Inconsistent: When the Most Accessible Experience is Different for Each User by Eric Bailey